The SMILES Trial: what’s the real takeaway?
Prior to 2017, dozens of observational and epidemiological studies reported that there may be some kind of relationship between diet quality and one’s mental health. Studies that have yielded a positive association between diet quality and mental health state that the kind of dietary pattern that may improve mental health outcomes includes a pattern that focuses on a whole foods nutrient dense diet inclusive of fruits and vegetables, whole grains, nuts and seeds, fatty fish, and lean meats, and decreased intake of ultra-processed and sugary foods. These observational studies allowed for possible correlations to be determined and until the development of randomized controlled trials, the field was lacking in it’s confidence to say that dietary interventions caused mental health outcomes to improve. Probably the most noted of dietary intervention trials, the SMILES trial, was the first randomized control trial (RCT) conducted in 2017 to assess if a dietary intervention compared to a social or “befriending” group, could produce positive mental health outcomes in a population of adults who were clinically depressed. Here’s their stated hypothesis: “we hypothesised that structured dietary support, focusing on improving diet quality using a modified Mediterranean diet model, would be superior to a social support control condition (befriending) in reducing the severity of depressive symptomatology.”
Method
Participants included in the study were diagnosed with moderate to severe depression via the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) and screened for poor dietary intake at the time of recruitment. Poor dietary intake was characterized by having a low intake of fruits, vegetables, other plant foods and quality proteins and a high intake of processed or sugary foods. Researchers also used a dietary score to assess compliance to the diet throughout the study. There has been some recent criticism of the specific recruitment strategies since this paper has been published, mostly because of the way they had advertised to seek out their participants. For example, there were advertisements stating: ‘We are trialling the effect of an educational and counselling program focusing on diet that may help improve the symptoms of depression’. If you are curious about the critique, make sure you read this paper. It specifically highlights how expectancy bias is likely a factor with respect to these results which is important to consider when we are thinking about the clinical takeaways of this particular study.
In total, 67 participants were included in the study and were randomly allocated to two groups. The dietary intervention group received personalized dietary recommendations based on a modified Mediterranean diet during 7 60 minute one on one sessions with a clinical dietician. Participants in the social support group received social support via a befriending protocol which consisted of regular meetings to discuss topics of interest or playing games. Here’s a description of the details with regards to both groups: “The dietary intervention comprised personalised dietary advice and nutritional counselling support, including motivational interviewing, goal setting and mindful eating, from a clinical dietician in order to support optimal adherence to the recommended diet.” Both groups met at the same frequency and duration throughout the study. Depression measures were assessed at baseline and at the conclusion of the study using a variety of self report measures including the Montgomery Asburg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS), which was the primary outcome of interest.
Results
After 12 weeks, results indicated that the dietary intervention group showed significantly greater improvements in mental health as compared to the social support group. “The dietary support group demonstrated significantly greater improvement in MADRS scores between baseline and 12 weeks than the social support control group, t(60.7) = 4.38, p < .001 (Fig. 2). The effect size for this difference was a Cohen’s d of –1.16 (95% CI –1.73, –0.59) and represented an estimated average between group difference, in terms of change from baseline to 12 weeks, of 7.1 points on the MADRS (SE = 1.6).” If you are familiar with nutrition research or in psychology, you would know that an effect size of -1.16 is absolutely huge. Typically, an effect size is considered small to moderate (d = 0.2 - .4), medium (d = 0.5 - .07), and large (d = 0.8 and greater) and it’s unusual to see an intervention with that large of an effect size.
It is important to note that beyond getting one on one counseling with a clinical dietician, participants in the dietary intervention group were given hampers of food, incorporating the main components of the diet, along with recipes and meal plans after each dietician session. This significantly increases adherence to the diet when one has the foods available to them in their home along with an understanding of the diet itself and how to cook specific recipes that adhere to the dietary guidelines. Meeting with a clinical dietician for 7 60 minute sessions created a guided individualized support system for the participants who were changing their dietary patterns and habits, something that can significantly increase one’s success with regards to behavior change. These are all independent interventions outside of diet that likely have created these extraordinary results.
Additional Thoughts
They conclude at the end of the study that modifying one’s diet to fit a modified Mediterranean diet, is a useful and effective intervention to help decrease symptoms of depression. In fact, here is what they state in the Discussion section of the paper: In summary, this is the first RCT to explicitly seek to answer the question: If I improve my diet, will my mental health improve? But I want to introduce the major confounding variables that I think, don’t allow us to simply come to the conclusion that diet indeed was the sole factor that caused these significant results. The “structured dietary support” which included meeting with a registered dietician on a regular basis, encouraged participation in a positive adaptive behavior (cooking for oneself). And we know that increasing one’s engagement in positive adaptive behaviors is a very effective behavioral treatment to assist with depression, called Behavioral Activation. It’s effectively, a behavioral strategy that increases a person’s engagement in positive and pleasant activities, thus helping to increase reinforcement, while decreasing punishing behaviors like social isolation, which tends to worsen depression. Behavioral activation independently has really strong effect sizes when we look at this as an independent intervention for depression. This, I would argue, is one of the main interventions used in this study (beyond modifying one’s diet). Meaning, the behavioral intervention within itself (cooking healthy meals for oneself consistently) allows the individual to not only engage in the adaptive behavior of cooking and preparing healthy meals, but it also inherently decreases the person’s engagement in any behavior that may exacerbate or worsen a person’s depression symptoms, simply because the person is now spending time engaged in this adaptive behavior. Additionally, tertiary interventions used like goal setting and motivational interviewing increased the person’s engagement in this goal directed behavior, which are hugely positive when it comes to treating clinical depression.
These are the confounds that exist in this particular intervention study and I think really highlights the need for us to be critical when it comes to interpreting these results. I think the more appropriate question here to ask is: If I improve my diet with the structured guidance and support of a nutrition professional, will my mental health improve?
With regards to the particular takeaways and conclusions we can potentially make from this study, I think it’s crucial to think about these above factors. If anything, the use of personalized sessions with a trained dietician or nutritionist to support dietary changes can be helpful in getting a mild or moderately depressed person to change their diet and that providing resources including handouts of recipes, as well as hampers of foods, increases a depressed person’s ability to adhere to these behavioral instructions.
Is it possible that diet helps to improve symptoms of depression? Maybe. But I think that it’s important to contextualize when diet is able to produce positive mental health outcomes based on the current evidence as well as these important factors of influence. Part of helping us understand this potential relationship, is also looking at other evidence for this relationship in prospective cohort studies. The benefit of the design of these kinds studies is that it allows us to determine over a longer period of time, typically in a healthy population (free of depression), if there is a relationship between one’s diet quality and the risk for developing depression over time. One particular review analyzing results of many prospective cohort studies assessing this relationship, reports that adherenece to a “high-quality diet,” regardless of type (i.e., healthy/prudent or Mediterranean, Tuscan, or vegetarian), was associated with a lower risk of depressive symptoms over time. But what is interesting is that they analyzed the results more comprehensively by accounting for studies that controlled for certain variables at baseline as well as looking at the difference in measures of outcome to see if that made a difference in this potential relationship. They found that studies that controlled for depression severity at baseline or that used a formal diagnosis as outcome did not yield any statistically significant findings. This is critical to understand as this means that a perons’s baseline status regarding depression severity mediates this relationship between diet quality and risk for developing depression long term. It also means that using a formal diagnosis vs. self report measures, are more sensitive to picking up on the diagnostic criteria for depression. Again, these are considerable factors that we need to think about when trying to answer the question if diet is really able to improve depressive symptomology in clinically depressed persons.
Increase BDNF and Decrease Depression: Can food be used as a therapeutic tool?
Research has been demonstrating a clear link between a poor dietary pattern and negative implications in one’s cognitive health and function for the past decade. There are likely many mechanisms in which this occurs and one of those is through a neurotrophin called BDNF or Brain Derived Neurotrophic Factor.
BDNF allows for neurogenesis, or the production of new neurons, and neuronal plasticity (our brains ability to change), which affects our memory and contributes to our ability to learn. BDNF levels are subject to changes from our diet and other lifestyle habits. In fact, levels of BDNF are significantly lower in many neurodegenerative diseases that include Alzheimer’s, Multiple Sclerosis and Huntington’s Disease.
Animal studies suggest that a brain structure called the hippocampus is very much associated with diet and our mental and cognitive health. The hippocampus itself is associated with learning, memory and mood regulation and is also negatively affected by depression. In fact, research has demonstrated that there are structural alterations in brain regions in patients with Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) that include the hippocampus and the frontal cortex (responsible for planning, organizing, and more complex behaviors). Not only that, but studies further indicate that for individuals who experience moderate to severe depression, the volume of the hippocampus decreases significantly and has been shown to decrease as much as 19%. And, the longer the duration of the depression, the greater the loss in the hippocampus.
Since individuals who experience depression typically also experience stress, further loss of the hippocampus can ensue. Furthermore, because self care activity and motivation significantly decrease in depression, it is more likely that individuals with depression are eating a poor dietary pattern. Cognitive Behavior Therapy, an evidenced based therapy designed to help individuals challenge their unhealthy thought patterns and behaviors, leading to the development and maintenance of healthy ones, requires an ability to learn and recall information. The ability to do so is already diminished in depression due to the reduced hippocampal volume and decrease of BDNF. Throw in a poor diet, increased stress, and lack of exercise, all common symptoms for a person experiencing depression, and you have a perfect storm and cycle of ever depleting BDNF levels and a continued decrease in hippocampal volume, all of which will also worsen a person’s depression. To this point, it would make sense to help these individuals increase their BDNF levels, allowing for neurogenesis, plasticity, and the increased ability to learn, to memorize and to better regulate mood. CBT therapy is all intended to help increase BDNF levels theoretically by having the person practice engaging in activities they used to enjoy, by increasing their practice of self care, decreasing and managing stress, and by helping to strengthen rational thoughts and frontal cortex activity. This hasn’t been statistically significant in any studies as of yet but positive changes occur in the brain as a result of CBT therapy that enhance frontal cortex activity and emotion regulation centers. Interestingly, antidepressants have been found to help increase BDNF levels.
With regards to a therapeutic context and including the typical cognitive and behavioral treatment for individuals with depression, I further surmise that helping a person to eat a healthy dietary pattern that is right for them, will increase their BDNF levels (beyond giving them other mental health benefits, see other posts for details), consequently, increasing their ability to learn and retain the information that is being discussed in therapy, and further allowing them to engage in the behavioral tasks that are commonly given by CBT therapists simply because they are giving their body and brain nutrients to support them in these goals. It is already incredibly difficult for individuals who are depressed to start engaging in the tasks discussed in therapy and without the raw materials to help support these mental and behavioral changes, the person has to work at least twice as hard.
Foods such as omega-3 fats, antioxidant rich berries that contain polyphenols (plant chemicals to have health benefits) including flavanoids, help to stimulate neurogenesis, reduce free radical activity, and help to decrease pro-inflammatory processes in the body, all of which help support the brain health of an individual struggling with depression. While high saturated fat and high sugar foods reduce the growth of new neurons, contribute to free radical production and increase the activity of pro-inflammatory processes. These results have been consistently observed in a number of animal studies. There is only one human study that found hippocampal volume changes as a function of dietary patterns. In this study, it was found that in a community cohort study of older adults, lower intake of nutrient dense foods and higher intakes of unhealthy foods (such as processed meats, desserts and chips) was associated with smaller left hippocampal volumes. This reinforces what we already suspected about food and our cognitive health.
Other ways to increase your BDNF levels include endurance exercise, meditation, deep sleep, and exposure to sunlight. All of these tools should be part of the conversation in therapy to help strengthen mental health and cognitive functioning. Even if you don’t experience depression, increasing BDNF levels will significantly change your brain function for the good by helping you learn more effectively, remember better, age slower, and regulate your mood. Who doesn’t want those benefits?
References
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12088740
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4697050/
https://server12.np.unimaas.nl/MHeNs_newsletters/Background%20papers%2012TTN/Sapolsky2000GCsHIP.pdf
http://downloads.hindawi.com/journals/np/2013/873278.pdf
https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/psychotherapy/how-psychotherapy-changes-brain
Omega 3's and your mental
Last week, I highlighted in my latest blog post that research within the last decade has shown that nutritional deficiencies exist in those with mental health disorders and that one of the most common nutritional deficiencies is Omega-3 fatty acids. There are now tons of supplements and headlines promoting the need for Omega-3 fatty acids, but do you know why? Why is this particular kind of fatty acid so important and how does it affect our mental?
Fats have gotten so demonized in our culture and unfortunately it has led many people to not have them in their diets. Fats are one of the three macronutrients (the others being proteins and carbohydrates) that we need to fuel our bodies and our mental. Fats are classified into a few different categories: saturated, unsaturated, monounsaturated, and polyunsaturated. Omega 3 fats are one type of Polyunsaturated Fatty acid (PUFAs). In terms of it’s chemical composition, this class of fats (PUFAs) consist of long chains of carbon atoms with a carboxyl group at one end of the chain and a methyl group at the other end. There are three main types of Omega-3s, Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and Alpha-linolenic acid (ALA). ALA is present in plant oils, such as flaxseed, soybean, and canola oils, while DHA and EPA are found most abundantly in fish, fish oils and krill oils. One of the most important roles in the body that fats play is being a major structural component of every cell in your body (Read that again: FATS ARE STRUCTURALLY PART OF EVERY SINGLE CELL IN YOUR BODY). All of our cell membranes in our bodies are made up of fats (phospholipids). They are important because they separate the cells in the body from their outside (their membrane) and they facilitate the exchange of nutrients between cells. This wouldn’t happen if not for fats.
Following consumption of these fats, omega-3 fatty acids are incorporated into cell membranes in all tissues of the body. Whether the source of these omega-3 fatty acids is fish, fish-oil supplements or food products fortified with the appropriate omega-3 fatty acids, measurable changes in cellular membrane content occur within days of increasing the daily consumption of these fatty acids. Dietary changes that include healthful PUFAs have a significant impact on the cell’s function. These fats help important signaling and communication within and between cells. Specifically, DHA, being the most abundant Omega-3 found in the brain, has been shown to be crucial for maintaining nerve cell structure and function. Both EPA and DHA have been shown to help the brain support healthy memory, cognition and emotional well-being. EPA and DHA also promote healthy blood flow, which is essential for brain function and memory. EPA and DHA are being studied extensively to assess the wide range kind of effects these two Omega-3 fats have on the brain. For instance, a recent meta analysis found that although blood EPA, DHA and total Omega-3 PUFAs are significantly decreased in patients with dementia, only EPA was found to be significantly lower in patients with pre-dementia syndrome, leading the researchers to suggest that EPA may be a biomarker and a risk factor for age-related cognitive impairment. This suggests that your Omega-3 intake, specifically DHA, can help possibly prevent cognitive decline.
Let’s take a look at some studies to see what the research has to say about how Omega-3’s protect the brain. The Easton Center for Alzheimer’s Disease Research report examined levels of DHA in red blood cells in a group of over 1500 men and women aged 67 +/- 9 years who were dementia free. The study measured the size of their brains and evaluated the subjects using a variety of cognitive assessments. Results indicated that those individuals having the lowest DHA levels had significantly lower total brain volume and greater levels of small strokes in their brain compared to those with higher levels of DHA. Additionally, those individuals with lower levels of DHA performed worse on tests for visual memory and executive function. This is more evidence that suggests that DHA protects our brain, allowing for optimal functioning despite the chronological aging process.
There is also evidence that Omega-3’s may be useful as a supplement for the treatment of bipolar disorder related depression and evidence that EPA-supplemented food is helpful in patients suffering depression. More research is needed to make this conclusive, since due to participant recall and diet-related systematic differences, there is complexity in interpreting the literature in order to make specific conclusions.
Although epidemiological research has shown that an increase in the symptoms of depression is correlated with lower intakes of dietary omega-3 fish oil, omega-3 fatty acids have not, so far, proved significant as a monotherapy for major depressive disorder. Individuals experiencing the symptoms of depression were also found to have lower serum concentrations of essential fatty acids, which was also revealed by several studies of EPA and DHA.
Besides treating depression, omega-3 fatty acids may also be useful in treating and preventing dementia. Nine epidemiological studies now support that increased dietary intake of fish is associated with reduced risk for cognitive decline or dementia with several of the studies showing a 40–50% reduced risk of dementia! DHA has also been shown to be specifically protective against Alzheimer’s Disease. One of the ways it does this is by limiting the production and accumulation of the amyloid β peptide toxin that is widely believed to drive the disease. Pretty amazing!
What happens when Omega-3 fats are used in conjunction with medication treatment for depression? Results of one study that evaluated Omega-3 fatty acids with and without SSRI fluvoxamine suggest that the patients treated with a combination of omega-3 fatty acids and fluvoxamine showed a significant difference compared with those treated with fluvoxamine alone in improving depression symptoms. Among women in the USA, depressed symptoms were examined in relation to intake of omega-3 fatty acids and omega-6 fatty acids. Higher intake of omega-3 fatty acids than omega-6 fatty acids was found to be associated with decreased risk of heightened symptoms of depression.
So does this mean that you can use foods rich in Omega-3 to help manage depression and mood disorders? The answer is yes, as a supplement to other forms of therapy that have been shown to be effective (i.e. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, exercise, stress management techniques). It is important to note that while these studies listed above all have promising and positive results, there are other studies that have been inconclusive or have shown that Omega-3s when compared to medication management for depression (i.e. an SSRI) have not demonstrated significant statistical effects. More research is needed to help clarify these results, specifically with regards to dosing, quality of the Omega-3s being used in studies, and severity of depression or said mood disorder. Other factors that may be responsible for these variable results are differences in sample size, biological and genetic differences among patients, environmental variability, and variability in response to Omega-3 fatty acids. It is also important to note that severity of the mental health diagnosis will dictate what will be necessary in order to manage the disorder. Someone with more chronic mood disorders that also have a strong familial component, might not benefit from the use of Omega-3 fatty acids as much as someone whose presentation isn’t as severe, or whose depression is more caused from environmental or stress related factors. Depression is a disorder that is caused by many different factors and depression due to insufficient Omega-3 fatty acids can be of one type. What this research does demonstrate is that eating nutrient dense whole foods that have a balanced macronutrient profile (fats/proteins/carbs) will have both short term and long term benefits for your mental. Disease accumulates in the body after months or years of “bad habits” i.e. poor diet, poor stress management, lack of exercise, etc. It is much more beneficial to act preventatively and feel the benefits that feeding your mental will have on your day-to-day life. At the very least, you will have improved energy, improved focus and attention, improved overall brain function, and increased satiety. Adding these healthful Omega-3s to your diet will only help protect your brain and other systems of the body (cardiovascular, immune).
The best sources of Omega-3 include fatty fish, such as salmon, mackerel, tuna, herring, and sardines. Other sources include grass fed meat, chia seeds, flax seeds, soybeans, and oysters. In terms of how much to eat? No Recommended Daily Allowance has been set for total fat or individual fatty acids, however, it is estimated that it is healthful to have these healthy fats be between 20-35% of total calories. It’s interesting to note that during hunter-gatherer times, our ancestors ate between 28-58% fat.
According to Dr. Janelle Sinclair, a biochemist and a registered natural medicine practitioner, in order to treat depression with Omega-3, you need to take a considerable amount. In fact, studies show that you need to take between 1000-2000mg EPA per day to treat depression. She further recommends that in order to treat depression, taking EPA over DHA is more effective and that the supplement is most effective when it has twice as much EPA as DHA.
I hope this helped to provide a general overview of how Omega-3’s can affect our mental and how incorporating this powerful nutrient can help provide long lasting benefits.
References
Appleton K.M., Hayward R.C., Gunnell D., Peters T.J., Rogers P.J., Kessler D. Effects of n-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids on depressed mood: systematic review of published trials. Am J Clin Nutr. 2006;84:1308–1316.
Cole G.M., Ma Q.L., Frautschy S.A. Omega-3 fatty acids and dementia. Prostaglandins Leukot Essent Fatty Acids. 2009;81:213–221.
Hegarty B., Parker G. Fish oil as a management component for mood disorders—an evolving signal. Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2013;26:33–40.
Lin PY, Chiu CC, Huang SY, Su KPJ Clin Psychiatry. 2012 Sep; 73(9):1245-54.
Marangell L.B., Martinez J.M., Zboyan H.A., Kertz B., Kim H.F., Puryear L.J. A double- blind, placebo-controlled study of the omega-3 fatty acid docosahexaenoic acid in the treatment of major depression. Am J Psychiatry. 2003;160:996–998.
Safa M., Fallah Tafti S., Ghassem Boroujerdi F., Talischi F. Clinical trial in the treatment of 80 Iranian patients with major depression disorder by the combination of omega 3fatty acid and a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor. Ther. Adv Psychopharmacol. 2013;3:186–190.
Wani, A., Bhat, S., and Ara, A. Omega-3 fatty acids and the treatment of depression: a review of scientific evidence. Integr Med Res. 2015 Sep; 4(3): 132–141.